
The X-Files franchise, to me, is a bit like the Simpsons franchise. The finest examples of their respective genres, both series continued long after the shark had been well and truly jumped, leaving the new generation with a sour taste in their jaded Jackass-loving mouths, while the dedicated faithful proclaimed their worth.
Had the mildly sufficient The Simpsons Movie come out 5 years earlier, it would have been the second coming, the pinnacle of all that is awesome about TV on the big screen. But it didn’t, and it wasn’t. And the same can be said of The X-Files: I Want To Believe.
It’s basically an extra long episode from the good-but-not-totally-awesome years of The X-Files’s nine season run. There’s no aliens and no government conspiracy, but there is a gay, commie, mad scientist with a Frankenstein complex, which is almost as good. Mulder and Scully are dragged back from retirement after an agent disappears, and have to solve the case of the missing organs, all while dealing with Mulder’s usual sister issues and a dying kid Scully refuses to euthanase.
The main fault with the flick is writers Frank Spotnitz and (X-Files creator and director) Chris Carter don’t seem to know their audience. They want to explain everything to the newbies, while at the same time shoving things in that only the most obsessed fans will get. It’s both dumbed-down and elitist at the same time, and that – along with generally uninspired direction - makes much of its execution awkward, leading to dubious critiques of Dubya, a lot of flowery emotional scenes that make no sense, and too much time spent on a subplot about Scully’s dying patient.
That said, I Want To Believe is not a bad film. David Duchovny plays Mulder perfectly, and Gillian Anderson's sceptical Scully is still a good foil for his obsessions, even if it feels like they’ve moved on too much to truly reinhabit their roles. Billy Connolly is a revelation as psychic paedo-priest Father Joe, who steals most of his scenes. Amanda Peet and Xzibit are serviceable agents, but don’t add much to the proceedings. The action scenes are engaging, the gore is PG-plentiful, and Skinner shows up at the end to be his bald, bad-ass self.
It can’t compare with 1998’s Fight The Future, but doesn’t really try to. It’s like catching up with an old friend. Simply a nice coda to a series that ended so abruptly and confusingly, and will surely make die-hard fans rest a little easier at night.
Had the mildly sufficient The Simpsons Movie come out 5 years earlier, it would have been the second coming, the pinnacle of all that is awesome about TV on the big screen. But it didn’t, and it wasn’t. And the same can be said of The X-Files: I Want To Believe.
It’s basically an extra long episode from the good-but-not-totally-awesome years of The X-Files’s nine season run. There’s no aliens and no government conspiracy, but there is a gay, commie, mad scientist with a Frankenstein complex, which is almost as good. Mulder and Scully are dragged back from retirement after an agent disappears, and have to solve the case of the missing organs, all while dealing with Mulder’s usual sister issues and a dying kid Scully refuses to euthanase.
The main fault with the flick is writers Frank Spotnitz and (X-Files creator and director) Chris Carter don’t seem to know their audience. They want to explain everything to the newbies, while at the same time shoving things in that only the most obsessed fans will get. It’s both dumbed-down and elitist at the same time, and that – along with generally uninspired direction - makes much of its execution awkward, leading to dubious critiques of Dubya, a lot of flowery emotional scenes that make no sense, and too much time spent on a subplot about Scully’s dying patient.
That said, I Want To Believe is not a bad film. David Duchovny plays Mulder perfectly, and Gillian Anderson's sceptical Scully is still a good foil for his obsessions, even if it feels like they’ve moved on too much to truly reinhabit their roles. Billy Connolly is a revelation as psychic paedo-priest Father Joe, who steals most of his scenes. Amanda Peet and Xzibit are serviceable agents, but don’t add much to the proceedings. The action scenes are engaging, the gore is PG-plentiful, and Skinner shows up at the end to be his bald, bad-ass self.
It can’t compare with 1998’s Fight The Future, but doesn’t really try to. It’s like catching up with an old friend. Simply a nice coda to a series that ended so abruptly and confusingly, and will surely make die-hard fans rest a little easier at night.